Skip to Content

How to Make Surprise Inside Heart Cupcakes

Surprise someone you love this Valentine’s Day with these Surprise Heart Cupcakes. One bite, reveals a red velvet heart shape in the center of each of cupcake.

Surprise Heart Cupcakes
Last week I spent some time in my kitchen organizing the endless drawers filled with cookie cutters, baking supplies and all my other cooking gadgets.  I was actually looking for a Mickey Mouse cookie cutter and when I couldn’t find it decided it was time to get organized.  In the process I found the cute mini heart shaped cookie cutters that I bought for this recipe last year. That’s right. Last year. I had planned to make these for a Valentine’s Day dessert to go along with our heart shaped pizzas but when couldn’t find the cookie cutters I had just bought, I gave up. As soon as I found them, I grabbed some cake mix from the pantry to finally make and share them here. Better late than never right? These Surprise Heart Cupcakes were the perfect Valentine’s Day treat.

They’re the perfect treat to surprise someone you love this Valentine’s Day. Plus they’re a great way to have everyone guessing on how you made them.  My oldest helped me bake them so he knew the “secret” already. My husband on the other hand had no idea how I baked that heart inside there until I showed him this post. I told him it was magic! Once you see how easy it is, you can try this bit of baking magic in your house.

The trick is using mini cookie cutters to cut heart shaped pieces of red velvet cake for the inside of the Surprise Inside Heart Cupcakes.

Once you have your hearts cut out, just stand each one up inside the cupcake liner before you fill it all the way with batter.
I went easy with a few boxes of cake mix I had in the pantry but if you have a favorite homemade recipe, you can just follow these directions and use that.
Here’s what you’ll need:
  •  Mini Heart Shaped Cookie Cutter
  • 1 Box of Red Velvet Cake Mix
  • 1 Box of Vanilla Cake Mix
  • Eggs
  • Oil
  • Water
Step 1: Follow the directions on the box of the red velvet cake mix and mix ingredients together. Using cookie sheet with a lip or shallow cake pans, bake mix according to package directions. NOTE: My cookie sheet was in use so I used these mini round cake pans since they were the perfect depth. Use whatever type of pan you have that is about 1/4 to 1/2 thick.
Step 2: Prepare Vanilla cake mix and set aside.
Step 3: When Red Velvet cakes are done. Set aside to cool. Once cool, use the cookie cutter to cut out mini hearts.
Step 4: Line a cupcake pan with liners and place a small amount of cake batter into each. Place a red heart in the center and cover with more cake batter until filled about 2/3 of the way full.
Step 5: Bake your cupcakes like you normally would. Once finished remove from pan and let cool.
Once you cut into them, you’ll find a perfect heart inside.
Now that you know the trick, it’s pretty easy right?
I topped them with my homemade Vanilla buttercream (that I can seriously eat by the spoonful for the perfect Valentine’s Day treat!)
 Valentine's Day Surprise Cupcakes

Enjoy!

Dawn

Surprise Heart Cupcakes

Surprise Inside Heart Shaped Cupcakes

Red Velvet White Chocolate Chip Cookies Recipe - A New Dawnn

Tuesday 14th of January 2020

[…] still one of my favorite cake flavors. But let’s face it, sometimes we just don’t want cupcakes or have the time to bake and frost an entire cake. Enter this Red Velvet White Chocolate Chip […]

Mini Heart Shaped Pizza Recipe - A New Dawnn

Monday 21st of January 2019

[…] especially on holidays. Valentine’s Day is probably one of the easiest holidays to make a fun recipe to celebrate the day with food. Since just about anything can be made into a heart shape, this mini […]

Valentine's Day Sweet Ideas | | My No-Guilt Life

Friday 28th of December 2018

[…] These cupcakes by one of my favorite food bloggers have a little secret inside. Is the way to your heart through creamy frosting and cake? It is to mine! Dawnn made these and shows you how to do it yourself HERE. […]

Cami Valenzuela

Thursday 11th of February 2016

These are so cute and such a wonderful idea. Definitely going to do these for my boys

Jamie Tomkins

Saturday 30th of January 2016

Those look amazing!! Pinning them to try. Thank you for sharing with us at the #HomeMattersParty